What are the benefits of a slower rental market?
What are the benefits of a slower rental market?
There are benefits of a slower rental market for both landlords and tenants. Yes I said there are benefits to a slow rental market, what are they?.
For tenants the benefit is the rental prices are usually on a decline meaning rental properties become more affordable. Other benefits are improved properties and easier moving process.
When the demand out paces the supply the landlord needs to be more competitive not just in price but in the product they are offering. When a tenant moves out and the unit has not been rented for the following month a landlord has the opportunity to perform repair work upgrading the unit. A vacant unit is a good time to repaint, change flooring or replace appliances.
Another benefit for tenants is an easier moving process. The tenancy act requires tenants to vacate their current property on the last day of the month they give notice by 1pm. If the unit has been rented for the next month that means another tenant is moving in later that same day or the following day. When the market is slower we often see units vacant for months or more in between tenancies. This means we are able to allow tenants to occupy the unit a few days before the tenancy starts which allows them to move out of their unit early, which in turn then allows them to go back to their unit and clean it properly. This is a less stressful process for both the move out and the move in. If the bundling is in apartment buildings or condos it also means it is easier to book an elevator as there is less moving occurring each month.
The benefits to the landlord are as mentioned it provides options to improve the unit between a tenancy. It also gives the landlord the option to consider other considerations. If it is a condo, house or townhome they can choose to sell the unit after the tenant has vacated the unit. Selling a property while it is a tenant can be difficult for access purposes along with the requirements for providing notice when the unit sells. If the unit is vacant, selling is tremendously easier. Sometimes the stress of the process of moving tenants in and out of properties can be difficult for landlords to manage. Any time you can have some space between the two tenancies it becomes a more pleasant process. When both the landlord and the tenant are experiencing less stress at the start of the tenancy there is a better chance of appositive tenancy existing.
What other benefits do you know of during the slower rental market conditions.?
Need help managing your investment properties. Cartref Properties can assist you, call today to discuss your needs. You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
Landlord use of Property, what you need to know.
Landlord use of Property, what you need to know.
During covid there was lots of noise over landlord use of property evictions. Oddly that narrative like many others has slowed down or disappeared in the past year.
Why is there less noise over the landlord’s use of notice?.
The reason there was lots happening during covid is due to the rapidly increasing rental rates many landlords were looking for ways to increase their rents to tenants. Landlords wanted the higher rent and were willing to try a tactic that would have the tenant move and then re-rent the unit at a higher rental rate. We are not hearing this in the current market due to the rapidly decreasing rents. Landlords don’t want their units vacant right now so they are not trying to move the tenants out. If a unit becomes vacant now a landlord could be facing multiple months of no rent, followed by the unit rented at a lower rent then it was before.
Many landlords found themselves on the wrong end of an RTB case when their notice to vacate for personal use was challenged by the tenants. The process for a landlord use eviction is very straight forward and clearly defined by the act. Section 49 of the RTA clearly states who can move into the unit after the landlord has said they are using it for landlord use of property. The only people who can move in are the owners (landlords), their spouse, parents or children or the parents or children of the spouse. This is a very small group of people for a reason. It limits the property from being used for anything other than immediate family.
When a landlord tries to move a person outside these parameters into the property under the landlord us provision they are violating the tenants rights. The government does not like it when landlords violate tenants rights. For this reason they have increased the penalties for abusing tenants rights for the gain of higher rents.
Many people say the process is hard to follow and one should seek help in doing this process. Professional help is always a good idea if you are unsure what you are doing.
The first thing you need to do is identify if the person who is going to live in the unit fits the description in the RTA for landlord use of property. If they do, the landlord can proceed with the notice to vacate. Starting in June of 2025 a notice for landlord use must be generated through the RTB website. There is no longer a form to fill out and send to the tenant. It must be filled out online and the system will advise if it is filled in correctly. It also records the people’s names and birthdates of who are planning to reside in the property. This data is collected for use in the event the tenant challenges the notice.
The notice must be delivered in a proper format according to the service requirements under the act. You may send documents by email if you have the tenants permission. If you do not have permission to send by email you need to send it in an approved form.
When you request the tenants move out a landlord must also compensate the tenant for one month’s rent to vacate the unit. This is often done by not collecting the final months rent before the tenants move out. After the tenant vacates the identified party on the notice must occupy the rental property for a twelve month period. Failing to do this could result in the opportunity for the tenant to claim the landlord acted in bad faith when evicting the tenants.
If a landlord is found to have acted in bad faith when using the for “landlord use notice” the penalty is a full twelve months of rent to be paid to the tenants.
Why have we not heard this as an issue in the past year?. The rental market changed and with a greater supply of products. Tenant’s are moving out of properties they don’t want to stay in. This allows the landlord to do whatever they want with the property. We are experiencing more clients electing to sell the property instead of re-renting the unit. When the tenant gives notice to vacate, selling the unit becomes easier as you don’t need to deal with tenants. Landlords are also taking the property back for personal use without the worry of providing the proper notice.
If you are unsure of your responsibilities for landlord use notice we suggest you work with a professional who can guide you through the process.
Need help managing your investment properties. Cartref Properties can assist you, call today to discuss your needs. You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
Government buying condos. How will it affect the rental market?
Government buying condos. How will it affect the rental market?
With the Provincial and Federal government combining to purchase unsold condos in BC how is this going to affect the rental market. This is an unknown question we may not be able to answer for many years. Many of these units would have been sold or rented at lower prices in the current sales/rental market as prices are declining. Now that these units are not part of the market place it will slow down the decline in prices, and it may not. It will depend on how the government uses these properties. Who will they rent or sell the units to?.
If the government uses them for lower income housing it may not affect the rental or sales market very much. It will take a long time for the government to fill these units with renters. The people they will rent these units to are not likely applying to the majority of rental properties currently for rent.
If they are units in condo buildings the tenants will be subject to the strata building bylaws. This may be a challenge for the government to manage on an ongoing basis. Government agencies are not set up to manage these types of properties long term. Who in the government is going to respond to and pay the bylaw infraction fines tenants incurr?
The bylaw infraction process is hard to navigate for the average property owner of a rental property. A government trying to manage thousands of them could be very interesting.
Maybe the government will hire outside property managers to manage these units on their behalf, which might be the best case scenario. The problem with this is the management company will want a fee that is profitable to them, I don’t see companies lining up to participate in this option if offered. This will increase the cost of owning these units.
The government may be able to manage them for about five years before they become too difficult and too costly to justify.
There are still a lot of new products entering the sales and rental markets and many already built products entering the sales and rental market everyday. We anticipate they will eventually turn around and sell the units when the market increases, taking the profits as any owner would. This may not be a bad thing as then they could use the money to build more purpose built rental properties for lower income families which is what is needed.
Buying these condos does affect in many ways the sales and rental market as it takes product out of the market. In a round about why this is going to slow the decrease in sales and rental prices which in turn increases the cost of housing to all. That is not the outcome the government is trying to achieve by purchasing these units. I am not sure I would call it a bailout, though I do believe there was some influence from the developers to have this happen even when they are saying differently. Many developers have come out to say they didn’t ask for this solution. If they didn’t ask for it then don’t sell the units to the government.
I could be wrong but I don’t think the government can force them to sell the units to the government. I would like to see some developers refuse to sell their units to the government in this situation. I am not holding my breath for that to happen.
Time is the greatest test of decision making and in this case we will only know in five to ten years if this was a good decision or not. I am predicting it is the wrong thing to do long term.
Need help managing your investment properties. Cartref Properties can assist you, call today to discuss your needs. You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
Short Term Rentals?
Short Term Rentals?
In the past landlords often rented to student tenants by signing an eight month lease the length of the school year and the students would go home for the summer.
We still hear of landlords doing these short term agreements or wanting to have time limited agreements where the tenant vacates the property. These types of tenancies are illegal in BC today and a tenancy agreement with a clause to vacate requires the owner move back into the property.
A landlord is allowed to have a fixed term tenancy agreement. Any fixed term agreement must end in one of two ways. On the standard BC tenancy agreement there is a section that the landlord must indicate how the fixed term tenancy expires. If the landlord selects box C indicating it is a fixed term they then must identify either box D which indicates the tenancy will continue on a month to month basis, or they select box E which requires the tenant to vacate the rental unit.
What many landlords fail to understand is that if they select box E it means a specified party must move into the unit. In this circumstance the specified person is identified in section 49 of the tenancy act, which states a family member, meaning the owner’s parents, spouse or children of the parents or spouse must occupy the unit. This is called personal use of the rental property.
This part of the act was changed in 2017 yet we continue to hear landlords who are signing tenancy agreements for specified terms with an expectation for the tenant to vacate the unit in six, eight or twelve months. We are often asked if we can find a tenant to meet these standards and clients are surprised when we inform them this is not legal in BC. If you create a tenancy agreement with this clause and the tenant elects to stay past the date you were expecting them to vacate the property, the landlord has no right to evict them.
It is these situations that have landlords ending up at the RTB in a hearing and the tenant being awarded the equivalent of a year’s rent to compensate them for illegally vacating them from the property. We recommend landlords use the standard BC tenancy agreement then have a lease addendum along with the standard agreement. Using the standard agreement gives both landlords and tenants the ability to clearly understand what the expectations are for the property. Using the BC form also means landlords are meeting the requirements of a tenancy agreement in BC.
If you are unsure of the laws for renting your property we encourage you to hire a professional to assist you with managing your property.
Need help managing your investment properties. Cartref Properties can assist you, call today to discuss your needs. You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
Do rent controls limit development?
The other day I was listening to a podcast, the wealthy Barber in fact speaking to an economist about the economy. A narrative that was brought up was that rent controls reduce and restrict development.
We hear this all the time from developers and landlords when they are restricted in their ability to increase the rents to current market rates. It is always reported as studies show that rent controls restrict development of property which in turn reduces the supply of the product. It was stated during the podcast that there are very few housing starts in Vancouver due to many factors including these rent controls. It is hard to compare two very different cities and regions when they build differently. Vancouver and the lower mainland build up, out of need which increases costs and time to build. I hear a comparison that Alberta doesn’t have restrictions so they build more. They also build less towers and more single family homes as does Ontario. Those properties are easier to start and take less time to build.
A quick google search shows that currently Calgary has fewer housing starts planned for 2026 than they did for 2025. Wait what, why is that? Based on the rent control issues they should be building all the time should they not? Why are they building less? The reality is there is only one factor that creates more development, how the economy is performing.
The current Liberal government wants to build more housing to make it more affordable, yet the developers are telling them sorry, right now we are not able to make it work and across the country are slowing down development. This is why there is great pressure on the development charges to be reduced to help developers build more product.
When the economy is going well developers will build and when it slows down developers stop building. We could remove all the tenancy laws allowing landlords to do anything they want with their properties, if there is no economy to support it they will not build. If you removed all the tenancy laws there would be no tenants.
We are experiencing this in Vancouver at the moment, rents are declining due to an over supply of product. We could build more housing now and it would sit vacant because there are not enough people to occupy the units. It is hard to build at a steady pace to meet all the needs of a growing city as it never grows at one pace. These ups and downs have occurred throughout history and will continue in the future.
I agree that rent controls can be restrictive and limit a landlord’s ability to manage their properties. What rent controls do for society is provide a balance of cost for tenants.
I wonder what the landlord would think if the banks had the same power to take back a property like the landlord’s demand when rent is not paid. If banks could sign one year mortgages and after that year raise it to any price they want nobody would buy a home.
Would they be demanding controls on what the banks are allowed to do in those instances? The answer is yes, which is why we have controls on banks ability to repossess a home when a mortgage payment is missed. It is not an easy process, it takes time and gives the home owner the chance to make amends.
During covid when rents were increasing rapidly tenant advocate groups were out in force demanding change to the system to protect tenants from escalating costs. Now that the table has turned and rents are declining they don’t really have much of an argument which is why they are not as vocal at this time. It is hard to argue that landlords should not be able to change the rent during tenancies when the rents are declining.
Every industry has regulations it must manage under to work in that industry. Hotels, taxis, bars and restaurants would all love more control over how they manage their business. Without rules and regulations we succumb to the whims of the few who have all the power. It is a difficult balance to obtain and will never be perfect. One side will always be asking for more. Our experience is that many landlords enter the business without understanding how the business works, they don’t know the laws. In any industry if you are unaware of the rules and regulations you must adhere to you are not going to be successful.
We think that some rent controls are a good thing for the industry as a whole. There can always be improvements from the tenant side and the landlord’s perspective. The majority of the rent controls in BC have been created due to tenant complaints about how landlords have managed the system in the past. Governments have felt the need to step in and change the law to protect the party with less power in the transaction.
Rent controls or restrictions are not preventing development, the economy is the only factor that encourages or slows development.
Need help managing your investment properties. Cartref Properties can assist you, call today to discuss your needs. You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com