Returning Deposits
Returning Deposits
Recently I was speaking to a landlord who advised their tenant had moved out at the end of September and as we talked in late October they were still working on obtaining costs for repairs before returning the damage deposit.
I advised him this could be an issue for him. BC tenancy laws require the deposits be returned to tenants within 15 days after they have provided their forwarding address. He advised they had provided the forwarding address at the time of the move out.
If the landlord has not returned the deposit within this time then you must file a claim with the RTB to obtain permission to keep any portion of the funds. Failing to refund the deposit funds in the 15 day time line, or not filling a claim with the RTB grants the tenant permission to claim double the amount of the deposit.
We often hear landlords dealing with returning the deposit while they seek quotes for repairs. A landlord does not have the permission to keep the funds for an undisclosed period of time. When the tenant provides the funds to the landlord at the start of the tenancy a landlord is holding them in trust until the end of the tenancy. They belong to the tenant unless granted permission by the tenant or the RTB to be provided to the landlord.
A landlord is only permitted to keep all or part of the deposits with either the tenants permission or from an order by the RTB. How and when do you get the tenants permission to keep the deposit?
At the end of the tenancy the landlord and tenants are required to meet and complete the move out inspection report. At the start of the tenancy both parties should have completed a move-in inspection report and at the end of the tenancy this same report if brought to the move-out inspection. Both parties review the report and identify any differences that are considered damage. If there is no damage the tenant provides their forwarding address on the inspection report form and the landlord has fifteen days to return the funds. We often hear of landlords who didn’t complete a move-in inspection report. Failing to perform an inspection at the start of the tenancy can revoke the landlords right to claim against the damage deposit.
What If the parties don’t agree on what is damage? In this scenario the tenants should still provide their forwarding address. If the tenant does provide their address then the landlord is required to file a claim with the RTB to keep the funds in dispute. A hearing would be scheduled and both parties would be able to state why they should be able to keep or have the funds returned. When a claim is filed the landlord will not return any of the funds until after the hearing is held. This could be months away.
What happens if the tenant fails to give their forwarding address?. The clock of the fifteen days to refund the deposit funds doesn’t start until the forwarding address is provided.
Often tenants think if they don’t provide the forwarding address at the move out they will wait the fifteen days and file a claim for double the amount only to be told the clock only started when they sent the claim to the landlord as that provides their forwarding address. A landlord would then be required to counter the claim.
There are many things that can happen when returning the deposit funds like:
-the tenants fail to appear at the move out?
-landlord never completed the move in report
-landlord has not calculated interest owed
-landlord has spent the money during the tenancy
Returning deposit funds is a very complicated process. Not understanding the process can cause a landlord to pay more than they expected.
Hiring a professional to assist with your investment properties is always a benefit. Cartref Properties can assist you, call today to discuss your needs. You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
When does the tenancy start?
When does the tenancy start?
We recently experienced something we have not experienced before. We currently have a unit for rent and showed it to a couple, who applied for the unit. We reviewed their references and offered to rent the unit to them.
Our process here is to send an email advising we are offering them the property. We request the applicants respond to the email confirming they agree to rent the unit. Then we explain what the next steps in the process are. This includes meeting to sign the agreement and collect the security deposit.
In this case they responded advising they will rent the unit. We drafted the tenancy agreement, arranged to meet the following day to sign the lease. In the morning they sent us an email advising they have elected to rent a different unit and will not be renting our property as previously agreed. This is the first time this has happened to us.
When we make arrangements to sign the lease we advise applicants that we will collect the security deposit when they sign the lease. Why do we collect the security deposit when we sign the lease?.
Under BC Tenancy law the rights and obligations of a landlord and tenant take effect when the two parties enter into the agreement, even if the tenant fails to occupy the unit.
We collect the deposit in the event the tenant elects not to move in. We have had people pay the deposit then elect not to move in and we kept the deposit funds towards unpaid rent as per the agreement.
Currently most tenants are in tenancy agreement and need to provide one month’s notice to vacate which means we are signing a tenancy agreement in October for someone who is moving in December.
In the case we are describing, the rental was starting November 1st. What we don’t know is, if the email reply we request is sufficient to be considered a “contract”. In this case we are not going to have the unit rented for November which means our client is missing out on the November rent. Does the owner have a legal case to hold the applicant responsible for the November rent they would have received?.
We don’t believe this would be enforceable in the RTB as the tenancy act is clear on when a tenancy starts. It may be enforceable under the CRT (small claims court).
Need help managing your investment properties. Cartref Properties can assist you, call today to discuss your needs. You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
Why do you want to be a secondary Client
Why do you want to be a secondary Client
The other day I was talking to a client who has a second property they are asking us to manage. We provided the proposal of our services and they would take the contract home and sign it back shortly.
About a week later we talked on the phone and they indicated they were going to send it back then the strata company who manages the building sent them an email offering a limited time offer to manage their rental property. The offer was for a monthly management rate well below ours and indicated there would be no placement fee. The client did identify they would need to pay for advertising, which can be very costly and the screening of the tenants. We do charge the cost of the credit checks back to the client. I assume that is what they are speaking of.
We recommended to our client, we understand you need to consider other options if they are more cost effective for you. We advised them, DON’T use the strata management company who is managing the building to manage your rental property in the same building. Our client said, “why do you say that”?. In BC the governing body for all licensed property managers is BCFSA. BCFSA has identified this as a conflict of interest and recommends it should be avoided.
What does BCFSA advise in this situation?
BCFSA the governing body advises management companies to avoid this conflict as follows:
“This potential conflict could be addressed by modifying your duties in advance by designating a primary and secondary client. The secondary client must understand and agree that the primary client the duties owed to them may be limited in certain situations”
What this means is before they are able to represent your rental property in the strata they are managing they will ask one of the two parties to sign a secondary client document. A secondary client document means there will be times they will not be able to represent you as their client (modify duties) due to the fact they represent the strata who are on the other side of the conflict. That is what modifying their duties means, translation it means not being able to act on your behalf due to the conflict. Why are you the owner of investment property signing an agreement that has situations where the manager of your property will not be allowed to give you advice on how to deal with the situation while they are under contact as your manager.
BCFSA also has a requirement that licensed professionals are not permitted to provide management services (offer advice) unless the party in question is our client. That means if a person comes to me and says we are the secondary client and the management company is not helping me, by the regulations of the licensing body I am not permitted to assist this person with their issue.
When are you going to have a conflict of interest with the strata corporation?. There are many times but the two most important are bylaw enforcement and emergency repair losses.
Let’s look at bylaw enforcement. When a tenant moves into a strata the tenant is required to sign a form K which is known as tenants responsibilities, meaning they have been given a copy of the bylaws and rules and agree to adhere to them. Many strata corporations don’t like tenants in general and can be quick to enforce bylaws on tenants, and often incorrectly.
If the strata corporation applies a bylaw enforcement on your rental in the strata they also manage they will argue on behalf of the strata corporation they are doing the right thing and the rental manager is not going to be able to give proper advice due to the secondary client relationship. Your rental manager, even though they are not the strata manager the company still represents the corporation and would be in violation of the primary client relationship if they provide direction contrary to what the strata perceives as correct.
What if the strata incorrectly enforces the bylaws? Are they able to fight to clarify this is being done correctly?. Simply no. If the tenant refuses to pay a fine for a bylaw infraction especially one that is incorrectly administered will be applied to the owners account. The RTB and CRT are full of cases where stratas have applied fines incorrectly and tenants have been awarded refunds or the fines cancelled plus costs of the proceedings. Having an outside party reviewing the process of the bylaw enforcement is important.
The other major time an independent voice is important is when there is an emergency loss.
An emergency loss can and often includes water affecting other units in the building. There are processes where the strata must have the owner permission to enter and repair items in the strata lot. If the strata investigates a water ingress and they make a hole in the strata lot they are required to put it back to paint ready condition. They often do not do this.
During an emergency it may be determined the damage is in excess of the water damage deductible for the building. Each owner has the right to engage the building's insurance policy on their own. We have seen buildings who don’t engage the insurance policy even when the damage is over the deductible amount then charge the owner of where the leak originated, the deductible amount to pay for the damage, this is the incorrect process under strata law.
When there is an issue at the building the strata corporation is making decisions that are best for the strata corporation and that decision may not be in alignment with the owner.
For this reason it is important to have independent advice on what the home owners rights are.
You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
What is a Form K?
What is a Form K?
Living in a Strata Corporation can be complicated, you own the home but unlike individual houses there are additional rules and bylaws residents must abide by. All Strata Corporations have “rules and bylaws” which are created by the ownership voting and approval at General Meetings. All residents including tenants living in Strata Corporations are required to follow the rules and bylaws. How do tenants know what the rules and bylaws are to ensure they are in compliance?
Strata Corporations are governed by legislation in British Columbia called the Strata Property Act. Section 146 of the act explains the requirement for landlords to provide tenants a copy of the rules and bylaws “before the tenant rents the property”. A “Form K” also known as “Notice of Tenant Responsibilities” must be signed by the landlord and the tenant before the start of the tenancy. The Strata Property Act also requires owners to provide a copy of the signed form K to the Strata Corporation within two weeks of renting the property. Many Strata Corporations have added bylaws making it a requirement that Landlords provide the signed form k as outlined in section 146, which provides Strata Corporations the ability to take actions including applying fines if a form K is not provided.
It is important to understand that having tenants sign the form K and sending it to the Strata Corporation isn’t all that is required. A form k is an acknowledgement by the landlord that they provided a current copy of the rules and bylaws to the tenant. When tenants sign the form K Landlord’s should provide current copies of the rules and bylaws, explain to the tenant why they are signing this form, as they are required to comply with the rules and bylaws and should read the documents provided to them. Another overlooked aspect is rules and bylaws often change during a tenancy. The Strata Property regulations standard form K identifies the need for tenants to comply with the “changed” rules and bylaws. During a tenancy, tenants may not be aware of changes to rules and bylaws unless the Landlord provides them with updates. A majority of tenants are not informed of communication in the Strata Corporation as the Strata Corporation will convey information to the home owners. It is the homeowner or Landlord's responsibility to communicate information to the tenants. After each general meeting Landlords should review minutes of the meeting to review changes made to the rules and bylaws. If they are changed or new ones added, Landlords have the obligation to provide the changed rules and bylaws to their tenants. When changes have occurred Landlords should have tenants sign a document identifying they have received the new or changed rules and bylaws.
Properly completing the “Notice of Tenant's Responsibilities” protects both the landlord and the tenant by clearly explaining the expectations of both parties during the tenancy.
You can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com
Stage one of a Tenancy
Stage one of a Tenancy
In a previous post I mentioned there were three stages of a tenancy. Stage one is the beginning of a tenancy. All three stages are important for different reasons. Stage one is where landlords have the greatest influence on creating a positive tenancy. Tenant placement is time consuming and should not be rushed. A Landlord’s goal in tenant placement should be finding a renter who will respect the property and treat it like their home.
Searching for a tenant begins with advertising the property and this should be done in an accurate and effective manner. You want tenants to be able to view the property and say I want to live there. Landlords should always use the most current photos. Every time a tenant moves out it is good practice to update photos of the interior and exterior, as the unit may have changed since the last photos were taken.
Showing a property is an opportunity to “interview” potential tenants in many different ways. Selecting a quality tenant is more than checking if they can afford the rent and will pay on time. A showing gives Landlord’s a chance to see if they will respect you and your property. Nothing is perfect, but I have found the following helps me find quality tenants.
Do they show up on time to the scheduled showing?
If they were late, did they contact you to advise they were going to be late?
How are they dressed and does that match their profession of work?
When entering do they take off their shoes or ask if you want them to take them off?
If you can see their vehicle is it clean inside and out?
These are some subtle actions that can show if a tenant will respect your property. If they show respect for your time and effort, their work, their own property and your property before entering I have found this often leads to a better tenancy. These are not the only things you should look for in stage one but they are a few small things that can make a big difference.
Looking for Property Management you can find more information about us at: www.cartrefproperties.com